JSM 2011 Online Program

The views expressed here are those of the individual authors and not necessarily those of the JSM sponsors, their officers, or their staff.

My Program

Abstract Details

Activity Number: 439
Type: Invited
Date/Time: Wednesday, August 3, 2011 : 8:30 AM to 10:20 AM
Sponsor: Section on Statistics in Sports
Abstract - #300218
Title: Foul on the Committee? Investigating and Predicting NCAA Tournament Selection Committee Decisions
Author(s): Jay Coleman*+ and Mike DeMond and Allen Lynch
Companies: University of North Florida and Charles River Associates and Mercer University
Address: Coggin College of Business, Jacksonville, FL, 32224,
Keywords: logit ; probit ; NCAA ; basketball ; group decisions ; bias

The NCAA Men's Basketball Committee selects the 34 at-large teams for each season's tournament, and seeds the 65 participating teams. The great debate that follows the Committee's decisions each year often includes charges of bias in favor of major conferences and toward teams with some sort of Committee representation. Another common complaint is that the Committee seems to set limits on the number of teams that can be invited from any given league.

In an extension of research on predicting at-large bids first published in 2001, we investigated the question of bias in the at-large selection of teams and the seeding decisions from 1999-2008, using logit and probit modeling. After controlling for team performance using 41 factors, we found evidence of bias in favor of nearly all major and even mid-major conferences in selection and/or seeding. We also found strong evidence of favoritism toward teams represented on the Committee.

A variation of the at-large selection model predicted 32 of 34 teams selected by the Committee for the 2009 tournament, and 33 of 34 in 2010. Had the model's 2010 last-team-in and first-team-out predictions been reversed, it would have been perfect.

The address information is for the authors that have a + after their name.
Authors who are presenting talks have a * after their name.

Back to the full JSM 2011 program

2011 JSM Online Program Home

For information, contact jsm@amstat.org or phone (888) 231-3473.

If you have questions about the Continuing Education program, please contact the Education Department.